Offsetters
Investor Relations|Careers|Contact Us
Offsetters About Us Advisory Services Project Services Education
Our Team Our Partners Frequently Asked Questions Current News
  • Contact us
    Archive
    2020
    June
    2019
    DecemberNovemberSeptember
    2018
    DecemberOctoberJulyJune
    2017
    NovemberJulyJuneMarch
    2016
    SeptemberAugustFebruary
    2015
    DecemberNovemberOctoberSeptemberJulyAprilMarchFebruaryJanuary
    2014
    OctoberSeptemberAprilMarchFebruaryJanuary
    2013
    DecemberNovemberOctoberSeptemberAugustJulyJuneMayAprilMarchFebruaryJanuary
    2012
    DecemberNovemberOctoberSeptemberAugustJulyJuneMayAprilMarchFebruaryJanuary
    2011
    DecemberNovemberOctoberSeptemberAugustJulyJuneMayAprilMarchFebruaryJanuary
    2010
    DecemberNovemberOctoberSeptemberAugustJulyJuneAprilMarchFebruaryJanuary
    2009
    DecemberNovemberOctoberSeptemberAugustJulyJuneMayAprilMarchFebruary
    2008
    DecemberNovemberSeptemberAugustJulyJuneApril
    Home» About Us» Current News» 2018

    Despite promise to Ontario, Ford cannot avoid pricing carbon

    When Ontario's premier Doug Ford announced that “as of June the 29th, the cap and trade system, the carbon tax, they’re done.” Ford was referring not to a carbon tax (which Ontario does not have), but rather to his promise to withdraw from the Western Climate Initiative (WCI), an inter-jurisdictional cap and trade regime which currently includes Ontario Quebec and California.

    Here and elsewhere, Ford has conflated “the carbon tax” and “cap and trade” in a manner that suggests the two are interchangeable. This should sound alarm bells for Ontarians, given Ford’s task was essentially to choose between the two very distinct carbon pricing systems: under the Pan Canadian Framework on Clean Growth and Climate, any province declining to implement their own carbon pricing mechanism is subject to federal regulation on carbon.

    The WCI is a cap and trade system, wherein the GHG emissions of polluting entities are limited (capped) though the limited issuance of emission allowances, and entities with allowances to spare can sell them to entities who failed to keep emissions below the cap. The result is an overall reduction in GHGs and an incentive for large emitters to curb pollution.

    By contrast, a carbon tax is paid by on all fossil fuel combustion by consumers at all levels, and while it is an effective way to raise funds for investment into climate change mitigation activities, carbon taxes have not been demonstrated to reduce GHG emission in and of themselves.

    By withdrawing from the WCI and declining to propose an alternative mechanism to curb GHG emissions, Ford leaves Ontario subject by default to Canada’s federal Greenhouse Gas Pollution Act: a bonafide carbon tax.

    The relative merits of a carbon tax vs a cap and trade regime are complex and debatable. However the very act of withdrawing from the WCI is likely to come with a high price tag for the Ontario tax payer. Ford has earmarked 30 million dollars to fight the Trudeau government on its (legally sound) right to enforce a price on carbon. But the cost of taking on Trudeau’s liberals in court is likely to be dwarfed by a bigger legal and financial battle: Ontario’s large emitters have already paid out $3 billion under the WCI, and are expected to come after the province to recuperate those funds.

    While Canada may be falling short of its commitments to reduce emissions under the Paris Agreement, the Pan Canadian Framework makes it clear that failing to price carbon is no longer an option in Canada. Ford’s remaining options are not between pricing carbon and not pricing it; they are between a robust existing cap and trade system and a bumpy ride towards a federally mandated carbon tax. In declining to propose his own alternative, Ford has chosen the latter.

  • Complete Offsetters Media Kit

    Download PDF

    Offsetters Investor Presentation

    Download PDF

    OffsettersOffsetters

    • Offsetters is hiring a Junior Analyst for our Advisory Services Department. Details here: https://t.co/VRVWOjfVCh… https://t.co/HPts22qoQj
    • Happy Holidays from Offsetters https://t.co/GvSpYxUQ2K
    • Burger King Dips Its Toe Into the Circular Economy: https://t.co/xBWbsZ6oc3 https://t.co/xJnLGaOoH8
    • Looking for the perfect holiday gift for clients or employees? @HemlockPrinters Wild World Gift Wrap is printed 100… https://t.co/Etjy5TyyKA
    • We're hiring a Client Engagement Administrator. Check out our site for more information: https://t.co/VRVWOjfVCh… https://t.co/Qjdaf3YBTw

Get the latest updates from Offsetters.

Sitemap|Privacy|Terms
RSS Twitter Facebook Youtube Vancouver 2010 Official Supplier